Reported or indirect speech: the essentials
You are advised to go through the guides on tenses, tense and aspect and modal auxiliary verbs before tackling this area.
Consider these pairs:
I was in London | He said he had been in London |
I can help | She said she could help |
On the left we have the direct speech – the words uttered. On the right we have reported or indirect speech – how the message is passed on.
On the face of it, there's nothing terribly difficult about this idea. The tense shifts back one (from, e.g., was to had been, from can to could. At the same time, I changes to he and so on. Here's a list of the changes in English.
Language item | Change |
Present simple changes to past simple | I am in London He said he was in London |
Past simple, present perfect and past perfect all come out as past perfect | I was in France She said she had been in France I have been to France She said she had been to France I had been to France She said she had been to France |
Present progressive changes to past progressive | I am writing to
him He said he was writing to him. |
Future will changes to would | I'll go later He said he'd go later |
Future will be + ing changes to would be + -ing | I'll be seeing
him tomorrow She said she'd be seeing him tomorrow |
Future will have + past participle changes to would have + past participle | I'll have done
it He said he would have done it |
Other changes | |
Pronouns change as appropriate | I / We / want to be there I / He / She / We / They said I / she / he / we / they wanted to be there |
Time and place expressions change as appropriate | I like it here She said she liked it there I am going tomorrow He said he was going the next day |
Modal verbs change to their past equivalents if there is one | I may see him He said he might see him I must go now He said he had to go then |
Using common sense |
Of course, not all changes are always appropriate (but using the
changes will usually be correct).
If we are reporting something virtually simultaneously, then we often
don't change the tense or time expressions. If we are reporting
something in the same place, then we don't change the place expressions.
So we might get:
A: I'm going there now.
B: What did he say?
C: He said he's going there now.
If an utterance remains true, we often don't change the tense so we
get, e.g.,
I'm from South Africa =
He said he's from
South Africa
I love the countryside = She said she loves
the countryside
and no changes are necessary because the fact remains true whenever and
wherever it is reported.
Try this matching exercise.
Did you notice the changes, particularly with time and place expressions but also with the verb come (which changed to go)?
Teaching issues |
There is nothing very difficult about the form of reported speech changes (providing a learner is already familiar with the tense forms of English). However:
- Because of the common sense issues touched on above, you need to make sure that the language is very clearly set in a time-and-place context.
- It is almost impossible to practise the form changes in class by getting students to report each others' utterances because time and place remain static. You need to spread the practice over time and place to be authentic.
- You need to make sure that learners are aware of the common sense issues and don't slavishly transform every utterance.
- Languages deal with the issues differently. Some, for example, reserve a subjunctive tense for reported speech and some hardly make any changes at all.
Related guides | |
reported or indirect speech | This is a more technical guide in the in-service area which repeats sections of the above but then it also considers reporting verbs and so on |
tense and aspect | an essential guide to the distinctions |
tenses | for a run-down of the main tenses in English |
modal auxiliary verbs | for the essential guide to the characteristics of these special verbs |