Expressing emotion
Unfortunately, this is an area where course materials often
content themselves with a phrase-book approach to teaching,
presenting learners with a list of verbs, adjectives and nouns (if
they even get to that level of classification) and then hoping that
the learners will somehow magically induce how the language works and what it
actually represents.
That is not the line taken here. The attempt will be at
some kind of systematic approach to the language of emotion.
Six types of emotion |
This site is not centrally concerned with cognitive psychology so you will spared an explanation of the various theories of emotion that circulate freely in the area. We are concerned, after all, with teaching and learning English so we'll focus on what has been proposed as the six primary emotions and their characteristics and see what language we can use to express them.
These six primary emotions are represented in the pictures above.
Click here when you have identified them.
- Picture 1
- Love. This can be further divided
into:
affection
lust
longing - Picture 2
- Fear. This can be further divided
into:
horror
nervousness - Picture 3
- Sadness. This can be further divided
into:
suffering
sadness
disappointment
shame
neglect
sympathy - Picture 4
- Surprise. There is only one
subdivision:
amazement - Picture 5
- Anger. This can be further divided
into:
irritability
rage
exasperation
disgust
envy
torment - Picture 6
- Joy. This can be further divided into:
cheerfulness
zest
contentment
pride
optimism
enthrallment
relief
The summary looks like this:
Based on Shaver, et al (1987)
This isn't the definitive categorisation, of course, and research continues. However, most categorisations of emotion will include at least the primary set of 6 above.
It is not as simple as it seems |
Given the complications here, it does not seem that a useful approach is to teach the language of expressing, e.g., sadness or happiness, because so much will depend on the sort of happiness or sadness we are talking about. Other areas are less problematic: surprise is pretty straightforward and there are only two sorts of fear.
See if you can add in some language exponents to this grid. You need to think of verbs, adjectives and nouns in each category. Then click on the to reveal some ideas (which probably won't match, of course).
LOVE affection lust longing |
Verbs:
attract, be fond of, draw, enjoy, fancy, like, long for, look forward to, love, lust after, prefer, tempt, yearn for Adjectives: beautiful, cute, enjoyable, gorgeous, likeable, loveable, lovely, loving, sexy, terrific, wonderful Nouns: affection, attractiveness, cuteness, gorgeousness, likeability, love, prettiness, seductiveness, sexiness |
JOY cheerfulness zest contentment pride optimism enthrallment relief |
Verbs:
amuse, appreciate, delight, enjoy, entertain, like, relish, take delight in Adjectives: content, delighted, enthralled, entrance, happy, keen, optimistic, overjoyed, proud, relieved, satisfied, serene Nouns: appreciation, contentment, delight, enjoyment, happiness, joy, optimism, pride, relief, satisfaction, serenity, zest |
SURPRISE amazement |
Verbs:
amaze, astonish, astound, flabbergast, shock, startle, stun, surprise Adjectives: astounded, flabbergasted, shocked, startled, stunned, surprised Nouns: amazement, astonishment, awe, bewilderment, surprise, wonder |
ANGER irritability rage exasperation disgust envy torment |
Verbs:
annoy, deplore, despise, disgust, envy, exasperate, grate, hate, infuriate, irritate, rage Adjectives: angry, cross, envious, furious, infuriated, irritated, livid, maddened, peeved, vexed Nouns: anger, annoyance, disgust, envy, exasperation, fury, hatred, infuriation, irritation, peevishness, rage, vexation |
SADNESS suffering sadness disappointment shame neglect sympathy |
Verbs:
empathise, exclude, leave out, let down, mourn, regret, sadden, shame, sympathise, upset Adjectives: disappointing, empathetic, excluded, humiliated, left out, sad, shamed, shameful, sympathetic, upset Nouns: chagrin, disappointment, empathy, exclusion, humiliation, sadness, shame, sympathy, upset |
FEAR horror nervousness |
Verbs:
alarm, disturb, dread, fear, horrify, panic, perturb, scare, sicken, terrify, upset Adjectives: alarmed, anxious, disturbed, frightened, horrified, panicked, sickened, terrified, upset Nouns: alarm, anxiety, fear, fright, horror, panic, terror |
There are some things to note when planning what to present.
- A large number of the adjectives have both the -ed and the -ing endings depending on whether it is the reaction or the thing itself which is being described. For example, shocking-shocked, horrifying-horrified, humiliating-humiliated, surprising-surprised, amazing-amazed. If your students aren't already familiar with this distinction, life will be very hard for all of you.
- Word formation is also an issue. Many of the words
derive from others by suffixation and occasional prefixation so
we have, e.g., sad-sadden-sadness,
like-likeable-likeability, cute-cuteness, sexy-sexiness,
fury-infuriate and so on. The rules are subtle and
the area hard to learn.
For more, see the guide to word formation, linked below.
It and Me |
The direction of transitivity is important.
There are five important ways to express emotion linguistically:
- Saying what it does to me.
It delights me - Saying how I feel.
I'm delighted - Saying what I think or feel about it.
I think it's delightful - Saying what it is.
It is delightful - Saying what it is like.
It is so delightful that I want to go again
Think of a way to do the above five things
with the six basic emotional categories
and then
click here.
There is, by the way, a good deal of overlap.
- Saying what it does to people.
We could have something like:Love It attracted me
She found it fascinating
It made her homesickJoy To her delight, he agreed
It gave me some pride
They made me feel at homeSurprise To her mother's astonishment, she married him
I found it shocking
It truly surprised them allAnger That irritates me
His actions disgusted me
They tormented herSadness I found it very sad
The response upset her
It was too shameful for me to recallFear It frightened us all
I made me a bit anxious
To our horror, the price doubled - Saying how people feel.
We could have something like:Love I was attracted
I was in love
She is infatuated with himJoy He's becoming more optimistic
It made her happy
He took heartSurprise I'm astonished
I'm flabbergasted
I was taken abackAnger I'm disgusted
He's appalled
I feel sickenedSadness She's a bit down
He was depressed for years
He felt humiliatedFear I am nervous
The children are afraid of him
I am anxious to hear the result - Saying what people think and feel about it.
Love She thought he was sexy
He fancied her
Mary thought it was lovelyJoy She was delighted by the result
They were happy with the room
I am content to staySurprise I'm shocked to hear that
He's bewildered by her anger
The dog was surprisedAnger Mary thought it was awful
I believe it's shameful
I felt they were exasperatingSadness It made her very sad
The music made her depressed
The news brought us downFear I think it's terrifying
That's fearful
How awful for her - Saying what it is.
We could have something like:Love She was very likeable
It's a memorable view
That's an attractive thoughtJoy Their enjoyment was clear
Her joy knew no bounds
Their delight was almost palpableSurprise My astonishment was obvious
Her bewilderment was total
Their puzzlement was expressedAnger His rage was obvious
She looked livid
Her fury was noticeableSadness His depression seems worse
It's a mournful bit of news
What a sad reactionFear That's terrifying
It's a horror
It's a fearful idea - Saying what it is like.
We could have something like:Love It's loveable
It's attractive
That's enticingJoy She's delighted
They are very pleased
That's optimisticSurprise What a surprise!
How shocking
That's an astonishing outcomeAnger They are infuriating
That's irritating
How annoying for herSadness It's like a black cloud over me
He looks down in the dumps
That is a grim feelingFear He's disturbed
We are all worried
That's concerning
None of these is actually very challenging structurally.
- Sections 1 and 2 are lexically the most challenging and
require
- the ability to use a number of verbs allied to the emotions
- knowledge of participle adjectives derived from the verbs
- the ability to be able to select which nouns are likely
to follow the To + possessive structure (as in,
e.g.:
To my horror
To my relief
etc.
- Using the nouns in Section 4 is actually quite uncommon but also quite straightforward providing one remembers that they are often modified by adjectives.
- Sections 3 and 5 only require the use of a very few mental process verbs such as think, feel, find etc. and knowledge of the verb be and some other copular verbs such as seem, appear etc. (Section 3 also requires some knowledge of the way we use the -ing participle adjectives, of course.)
Verbs: subjects and objects |
It is important to distinguish between the verbs that can
only have animate, sentient beings as subjects and those
which have people as the objects or can be used in both ways.
For example, we can both infuriate and be infuriated,
entertain and be entertained but inanimate objects or abstract
nouns cannot love, hate, relish, enjoy or be upset.
Using some of the example above, we get:
verbs with animate subjects only | verbs with people as objects and subjects or with inanimate subjects | |
love | love, like, be fond of, enjoy, prefer, look forward to, fancy, yearn for, long for, lust after | draw, tempt, attract |
joy | enjoy, take delight in, relish, appreciate, like | entertain, delight, amuse |
surprise | shock, surprise, amaze, astonish, stun, startle, flabbergast, astound | |
anger | rage, hate, despise, envy, deplore | grate, exasperate, irritate, annoy, disgust, infuriate |
sadness | upset, sadden, exclude, sympathise, empathise | shame, leave out, let down |
fear | horrify, disturb, terrify, sicken, scare, perturb, upset, fear, dread, panic, alarm |
All the examples for surprise and fear have people as
subjects and objects but no inanimate entities can be the subjects of
these verbs. By using a table like this, it is possible to
generate, for example:
I hate the noise.
The noise irritates me.
The film attracted her.
The book annoyed me.
She shocked him and he astounded her.
The sight horrified them.
etc. but the table won't generate:
*I irritated the noise.
*The dog surprised the shot.
*Peter horrified the film.
etc.
Languages handle these concepts differently and verbs which take animate or inanimate objects vary across them. Learners will make mistakes such as the last three examples in this list unless their awareness is raised of the possible subjects a verb may take.
Collocation |
This is a serious issue and lack of collocational knowledge
results in dubious (at best) comments such as:
I am satisfied to see him.
I am zestful to learn.
It always panics me.
She yearned for the book.
I felt a lot of upset.
He showed zest.
and so on.
Often, this is an issue of careful explanation of meaning.
Understanding of the meaning of zestful, for example, will
avoid such sentences.
Sometimes, however, natural collocation rather than meaning is the
issue.
It is almost always possible for native speakers to
imagine situations where unlikely combinations of noun and verb and
noun and adjective might occur but we are talking here about likely
combinations (i.e., natural collocates).
There are subtleties
of meaning and use which need to be carefully handled. For
example,
we can have | but (probably) can't have |
I am fond of this book. I always prefer sugar with coffee. She longs for him. The holiday tempts me. It's a cute garden. The game entertained me. She relished the opportunity. I appreciated his sympathy. The story amused me. An infuriated dog appeared. |
I am fond of this play. I always fancy sugar with coffee. They long for a raindrop. The story tempts me. It's a cute sky. The food entertained me. She relished the pencil. I appreciated his eyebrow. The beach amused me. A vexed dog appeared. |
Modifying emotion |
We can use a number of strategies to soften or strengthen the expression of how people feel. We can do this by using adverbs with adjectives and verbs, adjectives with nouns or by selecting a different word. For example
instead of | we can soften or strengthen it |
It's an enjoyable book. | It's an immensely enjoyable
book. It's a slightly amusing book. |
He's angry. | He's slightly miffed. He's (absolutely) livid. |
She's ashamed. | She's deeply ashamed. She's a little shamefaced. |
She's happy. | She's delirious with joy. She's quite pleased. |
I'm a bit nervous. | I'm extremely nervous. I'm terrified. |
I'm relieved. | I'm so relieved. That's a huge relief! |
There's a great temptation in this area to start to introduce all
sorts of inappropriate idiomatic language such as over the moon,
sick as a parrot, up the wall, going spare and so on. You
will find lists of such things on the web because people like making
lists.
This
is a temptation well worth resisting.
Teaching expressing emotions |
A cultural note |
Cultures vary concerning how easily people
talk about their feelings and emotions.
According to some, emotions are invariable across cultures
but how they are expressed and perceived may be very
different indeed. In some cultures, for example, the
outward expression of anger is frowned on and may even
result in social ostracism. In others, serenity is
preferred to zest and excitement and so on. Showing
too much relish in some activities may also be considered a
sign of shallowness and lack of sophistication.
This is an area to handle with some sensitivity, therefore.
A linguistic note |
Translating the words for emotions, even the primary ones above,
is never a risk-free enterprise. For example, the emotion of
happiness will, in some languages, include other notions, usually
peace and serenity as well as joy.
It is also claimed that languages have unique words for emotions for
which no reliable translation in English exists and the reverse
may frequently be true. For example, Mexican Spanish has an
expression (pena ajena) to describe the embarrassment one feels at
someone else's humiliation and English has freely borrowed the term
schadenfreude from German to describe the pleasure one may
take at another's misfortune. Dutch has a word (gezelligheid)
which in English requires a whole sentence and describes the sense
of togetherness one feels in being at home, safe and warm and among
friends and family.
As usual, context is vital if the words in English are to be fully
understood.
What's involved? |
The area requires approaches which combine structure, lexis and functional competence. It can't be done in a couple of hours at any level. As a very rough guide, you might consider:
level | structure | lexis | functions |
A1 and A2 | copular verbs. subject + feel / think / be |
the primary emotions and some common subdivisions | saying how you feel asking how others feel |
B1 and B2 | verbs forms to explain how things affect you | subdivisions of the primary
emotions -ing and -ed adjectives the more common nouns and verbs from the list above |
expressing more complex emotions being forceful and softening what we say |
C1 and C2 | all the structures with an understanding of the forms of transitivity | words to express a range of subtlety in emotions and finer distinctions | appreciating style, both spoken and
written in the expression of emotion subtleties of strengthening and softening |
Things to avoid |
- overloading learners
- in the categorisation above, there are six primary emotions subdivided into 25 areas. Clearly, that's too much to handle for most learners except as revision at higher levels. It pays, therefore, to be selective and focus on one or two primary emotions at a time, using level-appropriate realisations.
- scattershot approaches
- many course materials and worthy websites supply lists of exponents for expressing emotions of varying usefulness. This is the phrase-book approach and is unsuited to any kind of systematic handling of the area.
Things to do |
- obvious visuals
People respond well to pictures of other people. We have evolved very sensitive mechanisms for identifying emotions in others from their expressions and gestures. The 6 images at the top of this page, for example, work well for identifying primary emotions and the web is laden with images of people expressing various other emotions. Here are some but it isn't difficult to find more.
She feels..., He is..., She finds it..., She seems..., She's absolutely..., He's quite..., He looks a bit..., She is ...-ing etc. - less obvious visuals
People also respond well to pictures of things and situations which evince certain emotions. Again, the web is a good source. Here are some:
Note 1:
that people's reactions will vary so the emotions they record will differ. This is fertile ground for the discussion of why certain things evince certain reactions.
Note 2:
These sorts of pictures (of the objects of our reactions) evince different structures such as:
It disturbs..., It attracts..., It horrifies..., It surprises..., They are..., She seems..., It appears..., She's really..., It makes me feel... etc.
Note 3:
Pictures like these work well if the learners are allowed to use their imaginations and insert themselves into the scene. They can then produce language along the lines of If I looked under the bed and saw that I'd probably be very ... . How would you feel if ...? When I take a walk somewhere beautiful, it always makes me feel ... etc. - Inserting emotions into relating events
One of the guides in this section concerns relating experiences. It is a short step from there to getting people to enliven their stories with a description of the emotions of the participants. For example, we can enliven this:I took the tube to work this morning. When I got on the train it was, as usual very crowded and hot. Half-way to Euston, the train stopped for a long time. The driver told us that this was because of a fire at the station. After over an hour the train moved forward and we all got out at Euston.
by doing this:I took the tube to work this morning dreading, as usual, the morning rush hour. When I got on the train it was, as usual very crowded and hot. Everybody seemed irritable and I felt a bit claustrophobic. Half-way to Euston, the train stopped for a long time. Lots of people looked a bit irritated and some were clearly very angry. A few people also looked a little frightened and I was a bit scared, too. To my horror, the driver told us that this was because of a fire at the station. After over an hour, with my fear getting worse, the train moved forward and we all got out at Euston. I was really thankful and you can imagine my relief!
This practises both the language of emotions and the art of story telling (narration, if you prefer).
Related guides | |
word formation | expressing emotion often requires people to form adjectives and nouns from verbs |
adjectives | for the guide to an obviously related area |
copular verbs and complements | for the guide how subject and attribute are linked in English |
expressing liking and disliking | for a guide to how this related function is realised in English |
Reference:
Shaver, P, Schwartz, J, Kirson, D, & O'Connor, C, 1987,
Emotion knowledge: further exploration of a prototype approach.
Journal of personality and social psychology, 52(6), 1061